Smart grid faces security, consumer challenges
Going forward a myriad of issues need to be worked," said George Arnold, national coordinator for smart grid standards at the National Institute of Standards and Technology (NIST).
"One area we do need more work is in dealing with electro-magnetic events" such as so-called suitcase nuclear bombs or solar storms, Arnold said. "The military has systems to deal with EM pulses but they are just not practical, so we do need better physical and electrical designs to deal with these effects," he added.
Arnold and others expressed confidence engineers are adequately focused on making the future digital, networked electric grid secure.
"We have some of the best minds in the world working on how to protect the grid," said Arnold. "The problem I see is not in designing the products, but the operations practicesthat's where the gap is," he said.
Design for security has become the new mantra for engineers working on the smart grid, said Chris Knudsen who oversees smart grid standards and architecture efforts for PG&E. "I am very confident we are following best practices and that is the best we can do," said Knudsen.
"We have a lab that includes a complete substation and one that is outside the corporate firewall, Knudsen said. "We will take [efforts tested there] into pilots, so by the time you scale to broad services we will have a high level of confidence," he added.
The smart grid will also drive the creation of a new set of comms systems hardened not only for security but for harsh conditions and longevity. "If I am going to deploy a router on an electric pole where there is a high cost to touch it, it has to be reliable," said Michael Fuller, business development manager for a new smart grid group at Cisco Systems.
In terms of standards, NIST published an initial smart grid framework late last year but "it's more of an artist's rendition and an engineering drawing--its fairly high level," said Arnold.
For example, "there is a lot of work in industry to have a richer interface" between renewable DC energy sources such as photovoltaic cells and inverters who turn it into AC power for the grid, said Knudsen.
Meanwhile a committee hammering out powerline standards to connect consumer appliances to an energy-aware home network is making progress. It is expected to detail it latest work at a meeting in May, said Arnold.
"The consumer is the big kahuna," said Katherine Hamilton, president of the GridWise Alliance, a broad coalition advocating for smart grids. "We need to do a lot better job finding out how consumers behave," she said, noting the launch of an ad hoc group that will research the market.
"We also need to figure out how to calculate investment over time for benefit over time which is hard because we don't know how consumers will interact with this grid," Hamilton said.
Utilities have to show financial benefits outweigh costs of deployment to get approval for the expense of new systems, said Knudsen of PG&E. "We won't understand many of the problems until we get these devices out--we have a tremendous amount to learn," he concluded.
- Is rapid charging batteries really so damaging?
- Doped graphene nanoribbons promise energy efficiency gains
- Defining the EEBus for an efficient European smartgrid
- GaN Systems’ gallium nitride power devices, now through distribution
- Analysis innovation simplifies measurement of organic photovoltaic characteristics
- Can rubber bounce back to power lithium-ion batteries?
- Will 2D semiconductors threaten graphene's PV dominance?
- IP builds sub-1V Bluetooth Smart RF transceiver for wearable sensors and IOT
- Dialog collaborates with Energous to develop wire-free charging
- Nanotubular material opens new energy harvesting opportunities
- Spintronics discovery reduces low-power memory device costs
- Atomic scale imaging spurs high-temperature superconductor progress
- Power integrity solution delivers fast path to design closure
- Liquid alloy electrode improves sodium-beta battery performance
- Nanoscale study reveals EV battery electrochemical reaction insights
- Protecting against reverse polarity: Methods examined - Part 1
- Audi makes the leap to 48V supply
- Protecting against reverse polarity: Methods examined - Part 2
- Lithium-ion to primary battery power design conversion strategies
- Paralleled transistors and regulators eliminate need for heat sinks
- Is rapid charging batteries really so damaging?
- Study challenges Tesla's figures, predicts battery overcapacity
- EE Times' annual salary & opinion survey report
- Power Tip 74: Interleaving gets more power from a flyback
- Analog online resistance monitoring of resistive power loads - Part 1
- Battery-powered water splitter delivers low-cost emissions-free fuel cells
- Signal integrity and power integrity in high-speed design
- Solid state battery advance removes 'range anxiety' fears
- Low-cost isoSPI coupling circuitry for high-voltage, high-capacity battery systems
- Analog online resistance monitoring of resistive power loads - Part 2
- Smartphone SoC Power Efficiency - DVFS Capacitor Switching
- Power Modules: The New Super Power
- Digital Power Management Reduces Energy Costs While Improving System Performance
- How to Charge Supercapacitor Banks for Energy Storage
- Comparing harmonics mitigation techniques
- New Linear Regulators Solve Old Problems
- Non-Metallic Contact Power Measurement Ensures Safety at the Worksite